Saturday 11 August 2018

Ramming in Broadside and Ram


This was something that I really wanted to try out in the Broadside and Ram scenario that I devised for International Naval Wargaming Day. I had the Taureau as a test bed for the ramming rules and wanted to see how effective it would be against the Royal Navy ironclads, so worked out the following numbers using the formula in the rules and some logical thinking:

Taureau (1865)

Type       CS       MS        AF        DF       Points

AS           3         4            2T        6           11

The Cruise (CS) and Maximum (MS) speed was based on the formula in the rules, so that was easy. The Attack Factor (AF) was worked out by comparison with other ships in the rulebook that had a small but powerful armament, in this case a 24cm M1864-M1866 barbette mounted rifle breech loader, so a rating or 2T seemed fair. 

The T reflects the barbette mounting, which was not a turret but would have allowed fire forwards and to either side, but not in 360 degrees. I decided to not allow fire backwards along the length of the ship to keep things simple but, in retrospect, should really should only have allowed a 180 degree arc of fire forwards. 

The rules give a -1 penalty for firing for turrets firing along the centreline but I'm pretty sure a barbette mounting wouldn't be able to do this anyway?


The armour rating was based on other armoured or ironclad ships of a similar standard and also reflected the fact that the hull was rounded, offering a very small target area. I wondered about knocking the DF down to 5 but, as the Taureau was operating independently for most of the scenario with a -1 DF penalty as a result, this didn't seem necessary. 

As far as the ramming went, it seems that the jury is still out, with a failed attack against HMS Warrior due to rubbish dice rolling. I changed the rules to give specialised rams a 2D6 base roll for ramming instead of 1D6, as otherwise they wouldn't have any advantage despite their purpose built design. This worked well in practice, despite the poor result, so I think I'll keep it.


However, after the ram attack there were no rules for disengaging, which seemed a bit of an oversight. I may well add this as an AP option at the start of the subsequent turn, with 1 AP required by either ship to break free. This means that if neither side spends the AP the two ships will remain locked together, which would be a realistic outcome, the AP having to be spent to order the crew to cut the two vessels free, plug the hole and push away from the enemy.

I will pop these ideas off to David Manley and see if he thinks they are workable?

1 comment:

  1. After some further research I've decided to bump the DF down to 5, primarily due to the wooden construction of the hull, which according to the experts at the time would not have sustained the impact of a ram attack.

    ReplyDelete

Labels

Bag The Hun (849) Books (501) AK47 (499) Ironclads (489) Wings at War (415) Pre-Dreadnoughts (243) Back of Beyond (242) Coastal Warfare (225) Napoleonic Naval (200) Britain's Small Wars (199) Bolt Action (175) Victory at Sea (171) What a Tanker (171) Target Locked On (163) MiG Alley (160) Knights of the Sky (159) Chain of Command (149) Old West (147) Find Fix and Strike (138) Bag The MiG (126) Naval Thunder (120) Sandbox Skirmish (119) Naval Command (118) Pirates (116) Air War Over Khalkhin Gol (115) Indo China / Vietnam (114) Fistful of Lead (109) 15mm Sci-Fi / Near Future (95) Darkest Africa (91) VBCW (89) Strength and Honour (86) Continuation War (82) Ancients (81) Shows (79) ACW (77) The Football War (76) Corsairs and Cavaliers (71) Boardgames (67) France's Small Wars (67) Shipwreck! (66) BKC (65) Rapid Fire (63) Saurian Safari (62) Cruel Seas (60) Saga (60) Air War C21 (59) Journals (58) The Men Who Would Be Kings (58) Nimitz (55) Flashpoint Alto Cenepa (53) IABSM (53) International Naval Wargaming Day (53) Gladiators (51) Flashpoint Taiwan (50) Finest Hour (49) Red Actions! (47) Fortifications (46) Scramble for Britain (45) Flashpoint Baltic (42) Duel of Aces (41) War of the Pacific (40) Cold War (39) Flames above the Falklands (38) Thud Ridge (37) SCW (36) Desert Spitfires (35) Death in the Dark Continent (34) RCW (34) Algernon Pulls It Off (32) Atlantic Wall (31) English Civil War / Anglo Dutch War Naval (31) Lion Rampant (31) Post Apocalypse (31) Iron Cow (30) Bag the Springbok (29) Mexican Revolution (28) Normandy Firefight (28) Full Thrust (27) Dreadnoughts (26) It Rolls For Ivan (26) Bulldogs Away! (24) One Hour Wargames (24) Samurai (24) Jet Knights of the Sky (23) 28mm English Civil War (22) Imaginations (22) Achtung Kommando! (21) Arctic Eagles (21) Flashpoint PVO (21) Ancient Naval (20) PITS (20) Galactic Heroes (19) Steamer Wars (19) Strontium Dog (19) Iron Cross (18) Winter War (18) 2mm English Civil War (15) Aeronef (15) Aircraft (15) Imperial Commander (15) Rate of Fire (15) Zulus! (15) Aliens (14) Dragon Rampant (14) Black Ops (13) CY6 Jet Age (13) Congo (13) Mad for War (13) Impetus (12) Wars of Insurgency (12) Flashpoint Fleet Air Arm (11) Gaslands (11) 633 Squadron (10) Franco Thai Air War (10) Get the Goeben! (10) Jungle Green (10) Sharp Practice (10) 28mm Future Wars (9) Bohica (9) Dux Britanniarum (9) Fire in the Sky (9) HYW (9) Merry Xmas Mr Sankara (9) Adventures in Jimland (8) Bombers over Germany (8) Cry Havoc (8) French Indian Wars (8) Renaissance Naval (8) Star Wars Legion (8) Sword and Spear (8) Through The Mud and Blood (8) Air War Angola (7) Frostgrave (7) Target for Tonight (7) A Mighty Fortress (6) AirWar:1918 (6) Five Parsecs From Home (6) French Resistance (6) Check Your Six! (5) Five Men at Kursk (5) Fivecore Skirmish (5) Maurice (5) Seven Days to the River Rhine (5) Three Musketeers (5) What a Cowboy (5) Wings Over Suez (5) Arab Revolt (4) Corvette Command (4) In Her Majesty's Name (4) Infamy Infamy (4) Medieval Naval (4) Never Mind The Billhooks (4) Battletech (3) Gangsters (3) HOTT (3) Hind Commander (3) Lord of the Sea (3) Luft 46 (3) Mourir Pour l'Indochine (3) Sturmovik Commander (3) Whispering Death (3) Blood Red Skies (2) Chincha Islands War (2) Crom (2) Disposable Heroes (2) Fire and Steel (2) Fivecore Company Command (2) Iron Stars (2) Judge Dredd (2) Lethal Skies (2) NUTS! (2) No Go Zone (2) Pulp! (2) Starfighters! (2) War in El Dorado (2) A Billion Suns (1) Air War 1940 (1) Battlegroup (1) Black Powder (1) Convoy (1) Dropzone Commander (1) Falklands War (1) Harpoon (1) If The Lord Spares Us (1) Indo-Pakistan War (1) Lacquered Coffins (1) Load and Return (1) MiG Hunters (1) Missile Threat (1) Missiles at Sea (1) Naval Wargames Society (1) Norway 1940 (1) Oi Navarcoi! (1) Si Vis Pacem (1) Spanish American War (1) Sunray is Down (1) Ultracombat Normandy (1) Wars of the Roses (1) Xenos Rampant (1)