Tuesday, 2 March 2021

Fighting Iron Feedback

I played a simple two ship encounter game of Rory Crabb's Fighting Iron rules this afternoon to try out the system. This was an encounter between HMS Achilles and the Gloire, with the latter attempting to break out from the blockade of Brest in 1869, during my fictitious Anglo French War.

In Turn 1, Achilles won the scouting roll so deployed first in the NE corner, followed by Gloire in the SW corner of the table. Both ships then steamed ahead at maximum speed to close the range, the bowchaser crew on Achilles holding fire even though in long range as there was little hope of a hit, let alone any armour penetration.

In Turn 2, Achilles won the initiative again and continued straight ahead at full speed, while Gloire executed a 5'' forward move then a two point turn to port. Achilles now let fly with her port 7" bowchaser but, after some convoluted calculations, failed to cause any damage despite a successful hit.

The Gloire responded with a full broadside of eighteen 164mm rifles, achieving nine hits on the deck, casemate and belt. However, none of these penetrated the armour despite causing some non-penetrating damage, setting the rigging ablaze and inflicting some command casualties. These were swiftly dealt with in the following damage repair phase.

In Turn 3, the French won the initiative and the Gloire slowed down and moved ahead, turning one point to starboard at the end of the move. Achilles steamed forward again to bring her starboard battery into action in the gunnery phase. 

This led onto more buckets of dice being rolled, hits assessed, penetration calculated and damage resolved, with the end result being one penetrating hit on the hull, two fires, two crew and one command damage impact, all represented by a spread of tokens. The hull damage could not be repaired but the Gloire did extinguish the fires by the end of the turn.

In Turn 4, the French won the initiative again and the Gloire made a dash for the edge of the table at full steam ahead. To stop her escape, the Achilles turned two points to starboard and moved 4" forward, while frantically reloading her starboard battery. This brought the Gloire into close range and she lost no time in bringing her starboard battery into action, firing a full broadside at the Achilles. 

Again, after some more buckets of dice being rolled and re-rolled to calculate hits, penetration and damage, the result was a penetrating hit on the gun deck and four non- penetrating hits, inflicting a command casualty token, a crew casualty token and two fire tokens, most of which being sorted out by damage control at the end of the turn.

In Turn 5, the Gloire managed to escape into the Western Approaches while the Achilles turned to follow in pursuit. The end of the game gave the Royal Navy a very marginal victory, as the Achilles was only lightly damaged, while the Gloire had a damaged hull. The Gloire did make a successful escape, however, so I decided it was a draw. The whole game playing solo took about an hour, which isn't bad considering that I was working it out as I went along.

Overall, I enjoyed the game and found the rules easy to grasp, despite quite a few typos and mistakes in the text. It worked well and gave a reasonably realistic result, although the gunnery sequence was quite long winded and took some time to resolve. I liked the manoeuvre system, the simple gunnery arc diagram and damage tables, but I'm not so keen on the buckets of dice systems for gunnery, bearing in mind I was using broadside ironclads with loads of guns, or the tokens on the table which I find a bit intrusive. 

I'm not sure if the rules would work smoothly with more than a handful of ships a side, despite being presented as fleet level rules, but they're fine for smaller actions or for games involving turret ships, smaller ironclads or riverine craft. I will definitely be using them for another game or two, perhaps with my Peruvian and Chilean naval forces, and I think they will also work for my later Victorian ironclads... 

... just need to sort out those typos! 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Labels

Bag The Hun (852) Books (502) AK47 (499) Ironclads (492) Wings at War (415) Pre-Dreadnoughts (243) Back of Beyond (242) Coastal Warfare (225) Napoleonic Naval (200) Britain's Small Wars (199) Bolt Action (175) Victory at Sea (171) What a Tanker (171) Knights of the Sky (165) Target Locked On (163) MiG Alley (160) Chain of Command (149) Old West (147) Find Fix and Strike (138) Bag The MiG (126) Naval Thunder (120) Sandbox Skirmish (119) Naval Command (118) Air War Over Khalkhin Gol (117) Pirates (116) Indo China / Vietnam (114) Fistful of Lead (109) 15mm Sci-Fi / Near Future (95) Darkest Africa (91) VBCW (89) Strength and Honour (86) Continuation War (82) Ancients (81) Shows (79) ACW (77) The Football War (76) Corsairs and Cavaliers (71) Boardgames (67) France's Small Wars (67) Shipwreck! (66) BKC (65) Rapid Fire (63) Saurian Safari (62) Cruel Seas (60) Saga (60) Air War C21 (59) Journals (58) The Men Who Would Be Kings (58) Nimitz (55) Flashpoint Alto Cenepa (53) IABSM (53) International Naval Wargaming Day (53) Gladiators (51) Flashpoint Taiwan (50) Finest Hour (49) Red Actions! (47) Fortifications (46) Scramble for Britain (45) Flashpoint Baltic (42) Duel of Aces (41) War of the Pacific (40) Cold War (39) Flames above the Falklands (38) Thud Ridge (37) SCW (36) Desert Spitfires (35) Death in the Dark Continent (34) One Hour Wargames (34) RCW (34) Algernon Pulls It Off (32) Atlantic Wall (31) English Civil War / Anglo Dutch War Naval (31) Lion Rampant (31) Post Apocalypse (31) Iron Cow (30) Bag the Springbok (29) Mexican Revolution (28) Normandy Firefight (28) Full Thrust (27) Dreadnoughts (26) It Rolls For Ivan (26) 2mm English Civil War (25) Bulldogs Away! (24) Samurai (24) Jet Knights of the Sky (23) 28mm English Civil War (22) Imaginations (22) Achtung Kommando! (21) Arctic Eagles (21) Flashpoint PVO (21) Ancient Naval (20) PITS (20) Galactic Heroes (19) Steamer Wars (19) Strontium Dog (19) Iron Cross (18) Winter War (18) Aeronef (15) Aircraft (15) Imperial Commander (15) Rate of Fire (15) Zulus! (15) Aliens (14) Dragon Rampant (14) Black Ops (13) CY6 Jet Age (13) Congo (13) Mad for War (13) Impetus (12) Wars of Insurgency (12) Flashpoint Fleet Air Arm (11) Gaslands (11) 633 Squadron (10) Franco Thai Air War (10) Get the Goeben! (10) Jungle Green (10) Sharp Practice (10) 28mm Future Wars (9) Bohica (9) Dux Britanniarum (9) Fire in the Sky (9) HYW (9) Merry Xmas Mr Sankara (9) Adventures in Jimland (8) Bombers over Germany (8) Cry Havoc (8) French Indian Wars (8) Renaissance Naval (8) Star Wars Legion (8) Sword and Spear (8) Through The Mud and Blood (8) Air War Angola (7) Frostgrave (7) Target for Tonight (7) A Mighty Fortress (6) AirWar:1918 (6) Five Parsecs From Home (6) French Resistance (6) Check Your Six! (5) Five Men at Kursk (5) Fivecore Skirmish (5) Maurice (5) Seven Days to the River Rhine (5) Three Musketeers (5) What a Cowboy (5) Wings Over Suez (5) Arab Revolt (4) Corvette Command (4) In Her Majesty's Name (4) Infamy Infamy (4) Medieval Naval (4) Never Mind The Billhooks (4) Battletech (3) Gangsters (3) HOTT (3) Hind Commander (3) Lord of the Sea (3) Luft 46 (3) Mourir Pour l'Indochine (3) Sturmovik Commander (3) Whispering Death (3) Blood Red Skies (2) Chincha Islands War (2) Crom (2) Disposable Heroes (2) Fire and Steel (2) Fivecore Company Command (2) Iron Stars (2) Judge Dredd (2) Lethal Skies (2) NUTS! (2) No Go Zone (2) Pulp! (2) Starfighters! (2) War in El Dorado (2) A Billion Suns (1) Air War 1940 (1) Battlegroup (1) Black Powder (1) Convoy (1) Dropzone Commander (1) Falklands War (1) Harpoon (1) If The Lord Spares Us (1) Indo-Pakistan War (1) Lacquered Coffins (1) Load and Return (1) MiG Hunters (1) Missile Threat (1) Missiles at Sea (1) Naval Wargames Society (1) Norway 1940 (1) Oi Navarcoi! (1) Sea Wars Fleet Actions (1) Si Vis Pacem (1) Spanish American War (1) Sunray is Down (1) Ultracombat Normandy (1) Wars of the Roses (1) Xenos Rampant (1)